syswizard 

Wow , thanks much for that....very rare for sure. Can you provide a link to his room ?

https://www.tradertom.com/live-trading/

He's since added live audio commentary, which is very cool. If he's having a bad night, you might want to keep the young 'uns out of the office.

https://ninjatrader.com/events/
Jim Cagnina is darn good as a market analyst, but his trading leaves a lot to be desired.
This morning, he had multiple positions open on different symbols.
All were showing losses when the room closed at 10:15.
Cagnina uses: volume profile, VWAP bands, Support/resistance levels(S1,S2,R1,R2,etc), CCI indicator, fibonatchi retracements.

Look at Tradingresearchgroup.com It is focused more on providing an understanding of what's actually happening than a "watch me and try to copy me" type of room. They approach trading from both a structural and scalping perspective; both ends of the same elephant, which adds perspective.

mendal 

Those global stats come from Dr. Handley

Please be careful with Dean "DR." Handley, [U]this is my personal experience with Dean Handley[/U] he claims to have evaluated hundreds of rooms and says he has certain requirements for these rooms to be a trade "Titan".
Two of the requirements are they must have a verifiable track record and trade live.

Where my problem lies with Dean Handley is he advertised that he did all kind of research, and mathematical calculations and back testing on the NQ, YM, and ES futures that showed very profitable trades he made in a spreadsheet. He would sell this info to you for $199 in his webinars. I don't know if he is now, but a year ago he would revise these spread sheets frequently and sell the regurgitated material through another webinar.

When I questioned Handley in one of his webinars, I was thrown off the webinar. I asked about the results not being live, and he ignored my question. I then asked if he risked any of his own money in these trades and he relayed the results speak for themselves.

I asked, do you legitimately expect someone to trade a system live that you traded in sim and have not risked any of your own money on? I then made this comment, by your own rules your system should not be considered because the trades are not live, and your track record is not verifiable. At that point I was thrown off his webinar.

He tried in someone else's trading room to trade the NQ YM ect. from 6am to 8am. It did not last long.

Someone may want to look at this thread to get an idea of what your dealing with

Dr. Dean Handley So I get an unsolicited email from the good Doctor, see attached image, and I found the content to be interesting.... Anyone else get this same email?

Moderator Notice After reviewing his other posts in the forum as well as the flood of his posts in this thread, user @mendal has been banned and his posts deleted for vendor promotional spam, aggressively promoting the vendor Dean Handley. Bob.

faithdefender 

I am curious why Dr Dean has no credibility?? He is one of the only ones to expose many of the rooms. I am glad I found him before I paid money to Alla Peters room. I watched her do a Ninja Trader webinar and she reminded me of when John Lovitz does annoying man. I knew something was off in her presentation and not just her manner of speaking. I am very open minded and would like to hear any proof of his research being in error. I am glad he has done many videos and he constantly emphasizes track records right?

Hi faithdefender, this is my two cents on Dean Handley, I did not have a good experience with him and do not think he has anything to offer a trader other than hypocrisy and hot air. I spent $199 on one of his webinars and figured out very quickly he is a snake oil salesman and not someone that should be trusted, but you will have to be the judge of that.

Please be careful with Dean "DR." Handley, this is my personal experience with him he claims to have evaluated hundreds of rooms, which would be impossible to do in the timeframe he has claimed. He says he has certain requirements for these rooms to be a trade "Titan".
Two of the requirements are they must have a verifiable track record and trade live.

Where my problem lies with Dean Handley is he advertised that he did all kind of research, mathematical calculations and back testing on the NQ, YM, and ES futures that showed very profitable trades he made in a spreadsheet. He would sell this spread sheet to you for $199 in his webinars. I don't know if he is now, but a year ago he was revising these spread sheets frequently and selling the regurgitated material through another webinar.

When I questioned Handley in one of his webinars, I was thrown off the webinar. I asked about the results not being live, and he ignored my question. I then asked if he risked any of his own money in these trades and he relayed the results speak for themselves.

I asked, do you legitimately expect someone to trade a system live that you traded in sim and have not risked any of your own money on? I then made this comment, by your own rules your system should not be considered because the trades are not live, and your track record is not verifiable. At that point I was thrown off his webinar.

He tried in someone else's trading room to trade the NQ YM ect. from 6am to 8am. It did not last long.

Anyone interested may want to take a look at this thread to get an idea of what they are dealing with.

Hope this helps you.

Dr. Dean Handley So I get an unsolicited email from the good Doctor, see attached image, and I found the content to be interesting.... Anyone else get this same email?

trademe1 

Hi faithdefender, this is my two cents on Dean Handley, I did not have a good experience with him and do not think he has anything to offer a trader other than hypocrisy and hot air. I spent $199 on one of his webinars and figured out very quickly he is a snake oil salesman and not someone that should be trusted, but you will have to be the judge of that. Please be careful with Dean "DR." Handley, this is my personal experience with him he claims to have evaluated hundreds of rooms, which would be impossible to do in the timeframe he has claimed. He says he has certain requirements for these rooms to be a trade "Titan". Two of the requirements are they must have a verifiable track record and trade live. Where my problem lies with Dean Handley is he advertised that he did all kind of research, mathematical calculations and back testing on the NQ, YM, and ES futures that showed very profitable trades he made in a spreadsheet. He would sell this spread sheet to you for $199 in his webinars. I don't know if he is now, but a year ago he was revising these spread sheets frequently and selling the regurgitated material through another webinar. When I questioned Handley in one of his webinars, I was thrown off the webinar. I asked about the results not being live, and he ignored my question. I then asked if he risked any of his own money in these trades and he relayed the results speak for themselves. I asked, do you legitimately expect someone to trade a system live that you traded in sim and have not risked any of your own money on? I then made this comment, by your own rules your system should not be considered because the trades are not live, and your track record is not verifiable. At that point I was thrown off his webinar. He tried in someone else's trading room to trade the NQ YM ect. from 6am to 8am. It did not last long. Anyone interested may want to take a look at this thread to get an idea of what they are dealing with. Hope this helps you. Dr. Dean Handley So I get an unsolicited email from the good Doctor, see attached image, and I found the content to be interesting.... Anyone else get this same email?

Yes, it helps. Any first hand dealings are important. I will look at him with a new eye. Maybe he is taking out his competition? I'm not sure what his strategy is, but I thank you for the heads up.

n7ekg 

How's it going now with PTG? Are you still with them? Were you profitable trading the levels associated with the cycles?

As I get older, I am into Pattern Recognition Swing positions between holidays, rollovers, and significant events (FOMC meetings).
I do not track the cycles on a daily basis anymore; however, I still use the PTG method on the 4M chart to trade Open Range, if there is a good setup for Gap Play.

Hope that helps!

On the topic, any recommendations for ZB trading rooms/educators? Thanks.

I've seen others call out Tom Hougaard here......I can also say that TraderTom's Telegram room is as clear and transparent as one can get......I don't shadow his trades (i'm not that style of trader) - but I do follow him and read a lot of the tips he provides. He's obviously a successful trader and a good human being. He's easy to find....