Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
Apologies for the brief posts, as this was a live trading update and show how we use the theory of J-chart to have clear entry points and how the trade was concluded.
To recap, short entry at 7161 with stop at 7174
position close at 7121 via moving stop
As was discussed before, J-chart is very similar to Profile and POC with the difference that profile plots price levels traded at different times (A,B,C, etc) within a certain time span (i.e. 60 min, 1 day, etc.) and J-chart shows 5-tick increments traded at different price levels.
Now can you simply tell us what the vertical lines in your screen shot represent, 30 minutes, 60 minutes, 1 day, etc?
By the way, the pdf in your note #32 does not explain much the concept at all, it assumes you know what every thing on that chart is. All it says is how good j chart is and how everything else is worthless. Can you provide a reference for more detail on how the chart is constructed, interpreted and traded.
Ditto! I think if someone modify the Market Profile indicator to draw tick bars instead of volume bars at different price levels it will be exactly the J-chart.
i think that it is very unfair of you to say such things, i have replied to Big Mike when asked, that i am not selling any thing and i have not, now or in future. I challenge anyone who think/feel that i am not speaking the truth on this matter to produce evidence that i am trying to sell anything to anyone.
Your comment i think are in very bad faith and an attack on my integrity, to claim that i am guilty of such intentions when there are non.
I will iterate again that i am not selling anything and i am just discussing the forecasting method of J-Chart.
theSeeker post a link in his post 30 which does give an overview of J-Chart including how it is constructed, how it was used and also difference between J-Chart and Market Profile. Also towards the end of the pdf which i have uploaded, there is an explanation on a trade, did you read both?
Do not be constrained by fixed time intervals, the vertical lines depend on the needs on how to find equilibrium, it could be 2.1 days, 1.1 hrs etc.
Be cool ecmf, some people may be frustrated with your style of piece meal explaining (or non-explaining) of the J-Chart method without really revealing substantial insights. Unless you can explain in detail the method (Logic, construction, interpretation, trading rules, etc.) and provide some actual before-the-fact predictions people are going to think you are just making a plug (although unintentional). People need to understand it before they become interested and say WOW!
Here on futures.io (formerly BMT) we have a bunch no none sense sharp coders and expert advisers that are very helpful and share details with all unselfishly. We have had experience with vendors or vendor pushers in the past, so its easy for people to become suspicious.
If J-Chart is truly a good trading tool then it deserves a proper introduction to attract new interest.
I am open to questions asked about the method and for discussion on the method, but i do think that it is bad and very unfair to openly hint that i have ulterior motives to push any services or software in discussing my method when there are no evidence.
So I am now guilty unless proven innocent?
In my first post, i did make a forecast before the event which you are welcome to check, and i did make a few others. Earlier i made a series of posts on a Taiwan index futures trade.
I do take note of your complaints that there seem to be nothing substantial, but i feel and hope that theSeeker's link and my uploaded pdf with examples do have some substance of interest.
Unfortunately Mr John Chen's book was published in Chinese and i do have to read a couple of times before the theory sink in and i will fully admit i have only scratched the surface.
Do bear with me as i attempt to do my best to explain the theory to do justice to Mr John's findings which i feel is more important than the software. Once the concepts are known, you can do it in whatever way you want. Most people are used to seeing candlesticks or bar charts and it is quite difficult to explain a radical change in the way the charts are presented and interpreted.