Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now, It is Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
You can lookup the firms NFA Broker ID from within the complaint form. It will also ask for any details about your complaint, and your contact information.
If you want to additionally file a CFTC complaint:
The CFTC complaint can be done in addition to the NFA complaint.
Why do I share this information? Simple. Many members of our community have run into unfair business practices from their broker. Whether it is lying about all-in commission costs, or conveniently "correcting the problem" with billing you one commission but promising another, or technical issues that result in losses that are their fault, or even mis-management practices such as accepting borderless bank transfers (against KYC or AML one would think) ...
The thing is, when you step back and take a wide-angle view like me, you see a lot of these things repeat themselves frequently. Especially the commissions one. But as an individual trader, you may think "oh, it was an honest mistake and they fixed it now". But if they do it routinely, it is simply a money making endeavor/scam on their part.
Why is it so important? Because you are putting all of your money at risk when you trust an FCM to hold it. There is no insurance when dealing with FCM's. SIPC only applies to equities, and to my knowledge the only futures broker that sweeps excess funds to a SIPC account is IBKR.
Mismanagement of a broker/FCM is crucial. Leadership is from the top, so if multiple problems exist in their ranks, then eventually it can lead to closure of the FCM and loss of all clients money. Having your money in a segregated account is no guarantee, just look at all the past FCM's that went belly up and left their clients with losses.
So please, take the time to file an NFA complaint if you have been wronged by your broker. Let the NFA decide if their is a pattern worthy of action.
I second this. While your claim may be judged dubious it is important to keep the broker/FCM above water in their dealings. If multiple claims get made the regulating body will see the pattern that the individual might not.
I have a question. Where would the appropriate venue be to talk about an issue. I have one that I'm sure other have experienced (but is not completely clear who and what is at fault), and think that public knowledge of it, regardless of result, would help not only the community, but hold everyone accountable and bring to light the fuzzy area and line that is walked.
Just knowing how to approach claims and issues, knowing what is and isn't out of each parties control would benefit many people IMO.
BTW, mine has to to with incorrect, provable fills from a data feed and a company that 'evaluates' and creates a 'combine style' to introduce traders to funded accounts from a firm.
I'm currently transferring my TradeStation futures account to a different broker, and on my latest statement all of the contracts that were transferred were charged the standard TS commission of $1.50 per contract as well as exchange and clearing fees, as well as NFA fees. When I called TradeStation they said it was their company policy to do so.
