I'm considering trading the following combination of portfolios, but I don't understand which combination is the "better" choice and would like to solicit feedback.

Portfolio one consisted of 1 contract each of EC, GC & EMD with the following performance stats:

Total profit: $299,550
Avg Win: $1980
Avg Loss: $957
% Profitable: 40.5%
Win/Loss 2.07
Drawdown 14.15%

Portfolio two is EC & GC only, again a single contract:

Total Profit: $221,545
Avg Win: $3310
Avg Loss: $1410
% Profitable: 40.5%
Win/Loss: 2.35
Drawdown: 19.64

Which combination would represent the lower risk option?

Many Thanks.

Backtest results have little to do with future results.

That said, I will shout to @imPairsonator and see if he can spare some time to work his magic in answering your question. He has an excellent thread on a diversified portfolio here:

Developing a GTAA system In this thread I'm going to document the development of an ETF-based "global tactical asset allocation" system. What are the goals of this system? It's meant to take the main role of allocating a long-term portfolio. Hopefully we will …

Mike

First is better. If they correspond to the same period.
PF TP DD% DD$ TP/DD
1 299,550 14.15 42,386 7.07
2 221,545 19.64 43,511 5.09

Of course the DD are too big for me on both.