Any experience with Affordable Indicators - Duplicate Account Actions?

It's a Trade Copier for NinjaTrader.
It seems to be more advanced than Replikanto.

I have no experience with the Trade Copier or the company.

Lizard Indicators aka Harry Fat Tails. Take a look at their library. Entire library - one time fee for All indicators in the library - 195.USD
I highly recommend these guys.

gaz0001 

Any experience with Affordable Indicators - Duplicate Account Actions? It's a Trade Copier for NinjaTrader. It seems to be more advanced than Replikanto. I have no experience with the Trade Copier or the company.

I use the account manager/trade copier combo, and it's been very reliable. Joel is great to work with and very responsive to questions etc. I was using another solution, but a lot of issues made it very risky to use in a live account. I haven't any issues with this one.

Yes, been using it for over a week with zero issues. I had to abandon replikanto due to it never closing positions in a timely manner or closing them at all. I was always flattening my positions manually with them. No longer an issue now that I am using this. Joel is a nice guy and does respond quickly. Hope this helps

Hi @TonyDee and @BeMoreFree , an update in 2024 about our experience with Replikanto vs Affordable Indicators Copier?
I was wondering about hte differences. Cloing positions, slippage (I guess you can use market and limit?) etc...
Which one will you choose in 2024 ad why?

Thanks lot

Wil70 

Hi @TonyDee and @BeMoreFree , an update in 2024 about our experience with Replikanto vs Affordable Indicators Copier? I was wondering about hte differences. Cloing positions, slippage (I guess you can use market and limit?) etc... Which one will you choose in 2024 ad why? Thanks lot

I think there are a couple more free copiers out there, and I haven't looked at those. But I still use Affordable Indicators (with the account management add-on which is pretty sweet) and it's fine. It's important to have the right expectations with *any* trade copier, there will be slippage (sometimes in my favor, sometimes not), and there will be issues occasionally with orders being missed in fast markets. So having the broker windows/app open to monitor and manage your actual positions just in case is prudent imo. Yes you can run it in either mode (orders vs execution) and there are pros and cons to both. I think it depends on how often you move stops/targets around, and how close those may be.

Thanks @BeMoreFree

If you enter with a limit order and out of your10 accounts only 6 entered, can you continue and hande the 6 exit without worrying about the 4 account that didn't enter? if you need to worry about those 4, how do you do it? do you need to exit the account 1 by 1 or enter the 4 that didn't enter or the copy tools will handle properly what is enter or not entered from each account from the master?

Is the "account manager" you mentioned this one?https://affordableindicators.com/ninjatrader/indicators/account-risk-manager/

Is the account manager still useful outside of the funding account ie.TST or Apex)?

Thanks for your help!

Wil

Wil70 

If you enter with a limit order and out of your 10 accounts only 6 entered, can you continue and handle the 6 exit without worrying about the 4 account that didn't enter?

@Wil70, these are excellent questions about managing multiple accounts with a trade copier setup.

Regarding partial fills across accounts when using the Affordable Indicators trade copier with limit orders - this is actually one of the trickier aspects of duplicate account actions. When 6 of 10 accounts fill but 4 don't, you have a few options:

1. The Affordable Indicators copier tracks each account independently, so exiting on your master will only close positions on accounts that actually have positions
2. The 4 unfilled accounts should simply have their pending orders cancelled when you exit
3. However, monitoring your broker windows is still prudent - fast markets can create edge cases

Regarding the Account Risk Manager add-on - yes, that's the one @BeMoreFree referenced. Its utility extends well beyond prop firm evaluation accounts. For any trader managing multiple live accounts, it provides:

• Position sizing controls per account
• Daily loss limits to protect capital
• Real-time P&L monitoring across all accounts

The key consideration with any trade copier, including AffordableIndicators, is setting realistic expectations. Some slippage is inherent when replicating trades across multiple accounts - sometimes it works in your favor, sometimes not. The execution mode vs orders mode choice @BeMoreFree mentioned depends on your trading style and how frequently you adjust stops and targets.

Given your experience with delta and cumulative delta analysis on ES, you likely understand the importance of precise execution. Just ensure you test thoroughly in simulation across your account configuration before going live.

-- Fi
"There is a difference between knowing the path and walking the path."