Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
Being a Canuck, I am operating under some restictions. I only have a limited number of brokers that I can chose from that are can allow clients to open accounts in the US. And only some platforms, not all, are available to me.
I was thinking of changing to Market Delta because of their Market Profile suite, but I like Ninja Trader and I decided to try the 3rd party Market Profile stuff from Rancho Dinero. (Thats a cool name, dont you think?)
Heard a programmer trader of the suite speak on a Webinar yesterday, and I siged up for the membership. Still getting a feel for it.
It makes me look like an instant expert. But all the templates and the packages are based on market profile and contains TPO studies as well as trade planning.
Well, today was a down day, and i didnt take 1 short, unlike yesterday. I wasnt thinking we were going to keep going down and that the CL was oversold overnight. Boy, that was wrong.
All day long, I am trying to find a reversal, and finally, a wide range established price at around 97.50 to 98.50, on uncharacteristically big CL volume on a Friday, And a ton of volatility, 30 to 70 tick candles on the 5 minute. Today was a day not to watch the chart. A tiny small bodied doji was 20 ticks long!
Today, because of the fierce volatility, I tightened my stop...why you ask? Because I use a 15 ticks stop normally, and a 25 ticks stop wasnt enough, so my thinking is, if I am right, I will be right quick, and if i am wrong, my stop is hit in a blink.
Did it work, yeah, sortof. I stuck around way longer than I intended, only because i thought i was seeing history being made, and i want to be able to tell my grandchildren...I was trading the market the day crude went from 100.00 dollars a barrel to ____ (pick your number)
price went way farther than it should have, but thats the nature of investments...they always oversell at some point. The biggest up days in the market are historically after the biggest down days in the market. I thought today was going to be an up day, but now, its likely next week. CL has the weekend to think about where it wants to go from here.
IF the trades were market profile driven, and I am not sure they were, days like yesterday remind me why I thought MP was the ultimate counter trend trading method.....support and resistance are supposed to hold except when they don't....and it seems like you can get run over on days like yesterday if you're not out quick if the trade stalls out..... this could be my unfamiliarity with MP speaking but I seem to remember wondering why the MP guy I was studying with didn't trade the trend that was very clearly unfolding and why he kept taking what appeared to me to be counter trend trades. Its why I bailed on MP......
Your thoughts????????????
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci
Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
First off, was the guy profitable? I assume he was, but just a lousy teacher. There are no bad students, only bad teachers.
Got a while? Keep in mind that as far as Market Profile is concerned, I am not nearly as experienced as many. But the concepts reverberate with me, because it attempts to quantify the market in terms of an auction process.
I think the best way to describe what I did yesterday is to call up my Time Price Opportunity chart. Each letter, if you are not familiar with it, coresponds to a different time on the chart divided into 1/2 hour increments. The purple highlight is the Value Point Of Control.
In Mind Over Markets, Jim Dalton describes 2 big questions that we want to answer so that we can trade profitable. they are.
1.Which way is the market trying to go?
2. Is it doing a good job in its attempt to get there?
On Thursday and Friday,the range was extended down in the early going, and then balanced on a tighter range after that. Firday was characterized by much more volatility and more volume than is generally. I missed the big range extention down, because the previous sessions market profiles didnt indicate price would collapse as it did, but the poor economic numbers on Friday likley had the effect of increasing the downward pressure that was residual from Thursday. Overnight we dropped 200 ticks. Thats a lot, and the market can run farther and faster than we can anticipate. I felt that after the open, I was anticipating a move to fill the overnight gap closer to Thursdays close. Thats why I was long on the first 3 trades, and I was not expecting the selloff.
Therefore, after 10.30 on, I beleived there was support. And as the session went on, it held. So I was long 97.70 to 98.20, when the price action on the 5 minute warranted. But if you look at the 5 minute, you will see, my 15 tick stop was bellow the support I had drawn, or the DB of the signal bar, and was taken right on that support. But if it moved up 5 ticks initially, then I would close to -10. I was trying to keep a 15 tick trail stop, and if I hit a 15 initial target, I moved to BE. I managed the trade manually from there.
It was an actively intense day of trading, not like Thursday where it was 2 trades and finished. I hung around a lot longer than I intended because I wanted to gain the experience of all markets, and no 2 days are identical.
I dont know if you have read it, but Mind Over Markets is a good book for understanding the method. Its seems to be working for me, but I come back to the fact that I havent been using it very long, nonetheless, I find it extremely helpful. Used in conjunction with PA on the 5 minute for entries, I am growing more and more comfortable with the technique.
It also have provided me the confidence to trade less, because now i am more confident of my entries and exits. Less anxiety there as well.
The teacher was profitable. He was a straight scalper using MP and I think a volume or tick chart. I can't really remember. I gave up when I could see a well defined intra day trend move in the direction of the extreme IB levels. He would limit order those levels and simply wait for price to get there. Some days he got filled and others he didn't. On the days he got filled, he sometimes got stopped out. Small stops to be sure because he was at the extremes but he also got ran over sometimes and slippage on his stops would be more than he was bargained for. On the days he got filled and made a profit, I can only remember on day where he held a trade further than 5 ticks on ES. That day he got like 40 ticks.....it was a pretty trendy day he happened to get lucky on I think.
On the other hand, I could see "signals" to follow a trend that ended up at his IB levels and a trader could be out of the trade by the time he was in it. I just couldn't see the logic.... Perhaps it was the teacher.
I've read Mind Over Markets twice. I get what he's talking about and I find the MP chart to be beneficial on the 30M chart for overall larger picture type stuff. I know Jim talked about trend days, rotation days, etc and how to identify them on the MP chart and how to take advantage of them. So far, I've not seen anyone make a good case for trend days on MP. Rotation days make a ton of sense from an auction market theory but these last two days seem to perform outside the auction theory at least in the smaller time frames.
Secondly, I agree with your support areas. I had them drawn as well and I even took a trade late in the day off one of those areas.....However, those areas look more like break down trend continuation areas than places to buy against the trend to me....I saw a HH/HL combination only once........however, if you made money, who cares what it looks like.... someone once said, do you want to be right or do you want to make money? In the end, who cares how it ended up in the account, only that its there.
I think I've been conditioned for so long to "trade the trend" that when something appears to contradict that thinking, I have a hard time seeing the logic or rational behind it.
Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, Leonardo da Vinci
Most people chose unhappiness over uncertainty, Tim Ferris
As Friday unfolded, I kept trading cause it was working.
Price was respecting the level at the support level later in the day, so i kept taking my swings.
The only reason I thought they wouldnt breakdown and further was because of the distance price already migtraed, and buying volum kept coming in to restrain price from migrating lower.
Now, as of tonight, there is a large gap dow, essentially the 4th day in row. I am going to keep a real tight eye on levels tommorrow.
Large gap down and huge overnight selloff, at least for the overnight sessions. Continuation of Friday? Are we going to test the lows of this year? Where is the bottom?
i have to admit, that much of my analysis is really out the window, because the last few days really dont conform to anything I have traded in the CL. Black September 1986...( I wasnt around in investments back then, but I read about it) All that merger aquisition collapse...Michael Milken, junk Bond Financing and the insider trader stuff with Ivan Boskey, and the RJR Nabisco merger with KKR, Ted Forstman, Greenmail...blah blah.
Well, i think oil isnt going to 0...or even 50 anytime soon. The world runs on oil...30% of our daily living expendetures are directly tied to the price of pertroleum. (I had a introductory seminar that I gave to prospective clients where I used that line...Surviving in Todays Economy)
Anyway...I took 8 trades. First 2 failed...a long and a short. -30 on those 2. If my 3rd one failed, i was going to call it a day and wait till tommorrow.
it didnt, and I survived to trade again.
8 trades, the later session trades off a S/R level that I viewed as 96.90 - 97.50.
-15-15+16+47+27+9-12+14= +71
No chart marked with entries today. I had it drawn, but I erased the thing after I had it all ready to go...hit the wrong icon, and poof. I wasnt about to redraw the thig from scratch. Not the first time it has happenned, just didnt feel like redoing it today.
It comes down to what you are comfortable. I can only speak for myself, and I have a short record in trading the CL. I know what I would like to do. Take only the trades that are successfull. I beleive fewer trades is better, and I think back a few months ago where I would be trading like mad...20 to 30 trades a day, which, when I look back, is laughable. not that there are those that are successfull trading that way, but for me, it just wasnt comfortable.
Now I feel much more comfortable, only because Market Profile has helped me to see the market in a clearer way. It has me focus on my risk ratio in a salient way, and has helped me recognise over all market structure and to pay closer attention to areas of suppoort and resistance. Seems to be working...
Broker: Advantage, Trading Technologies, OptionsCity, IQ Feed
Trading: CL, NG
Posts: 1,038 since Jul 2010
Thanks Given: 1,713
Thanks Received: 3,863
VV,
Does that TPO allow you to adjust the font size? Just curious. Also, if you ever wanted to only look at the TPO's (without the 30 minute bars), try and change the bar setting to "Line on Close" and just color it "White" to blend into the background. Maybe you have a feature on that indicator to hide the bars already but just a thought.