Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
As I'm making the progression to live trading very soon, I need to think a little on how to best and most efficiently (also important) document/track my daily trading performance.
How are you guys doing it?
In the past, I did various things, but was never quite happy.
1. I would use Excel to track my daily equity curve, i.e., initial account size, daily P&L and change in account size.
2. I would print daily statements from Ninjatrader. Maybe also broker logs.
Finally, and this might be a separate document, some comments on trades taken and lessons learned, i.e., a debriefing might also be of interest.
Any thoughts or suggestions?
PS: Trade frequency at this point is < 10 trades per day, so I'm not looking to track a huge amount of trades. Fortunately...
Tradervue is a cloud based journaling site with a slew of analytics and broker/platform imports including Ninja/Sierra. I had been keeping an excel journal and found it cumbersome to update and share with others. Tradevue's cloud implementation …
You miss 100% of the shots you don't take. - Wayne Gretsky
There was an FT71 webinar a few months back where he mentioned that he uses Evernote for journaling. I had never heard of it so had a look at it and installed the free version. That version has an upload limit of 60mb a month. I use it just for a comprehensive daily trade journal and use about a third of that allowance.
Initially I thought Evernote seemed a bit clunky and difficult to use but now that I have evolved a daily diary page that I am happy with, recording: premarket analysis and levels, goals, chart pics and today's important calendar news, market thoughts during the session; and finally post market review and a chart showing all my trades.
I used to write my diary in a handwritten journal but I found it was inconsistent and sometimes a struggle to read back. With Evernote I just duplicate the last page and swap pictures and rewrite the review sections. But the main advantage is that each day I add half a dozen tags to a page (you can add up to one hundred), and then I can easily sort and analyse pages, eg tags for 'Traded Poorly' or 'Missed Trade' or different instruments, days of the week etc. It makes it much easier to be able to look back at particular aspects and see patterns, set specific training goals to work on and generally learn something useful from your journal.
You do not win as a trader, you just get to play again the next day. If that game doesn’t appeal to you then you should not trade. Gary Norden
Edgewonk is tailor made for trading. Less than a month in, but I am sold on it. Pre trading prep and post trade journal keeps me from repeating mistakes. Not expensive either (although not free, some of the free things we use are the most expensive, in the end).
I'll be frank and say I was hoping I could be able to do this for 'free'. With a lot of other costs at the moment, I'm interested in reducing overhead.
I might consider staying with Excel for the time being.
I'm looking a bit more into the Performance Summary on NT8. It does seem interesting and offer some improvements compared to NT7. You can for instance plot notes for each day.
When trading live I use both output windows to print key statistics on a variety of things.
I track all my execution times measuring various key events.
NT has some of this built into their log files, but I measure additional execution metrics.
I have another KPI that measures toxic fills specifically.
I print the price level change data to the output window so I can track my trades relative to each price level and see where my fills hit.
I capture my estimated place in the queue on all trades and print this as well.
I do everything 100% automated, so I don't have to ever analyze why I did something. I am mostly collecting statistics to model execution speed, and seeing how various expectancies are playing out.
I just copy it from the output window into notepad, or excel. I have some delimiter logic I use to split everything nicely into columns.
It's a ton of stuff honestly, but without it I would by flying a bit blind and have to reconcile everything manually after the fact.
My advice would be:
1. To get your logs after your trades to see if your execution times were in line with what you were expecting. This is often where you can identify slippage from execution related issues. If you are lagging between Submitted > Working this is on you, your platform, internet. If you are lagging between Accepted > Working, this is on your broker. Some strategies fail if they are not executing within a certain speed threshold, especially if you use limit orders. Know what this threshold is, then optimize for this.
2. Get the price level changes in excel and then reconcile your trades against this based on your execution time stamps. You can learn a lot from analyzing your trades relative to the price level data.
3. As far as organizing everything... If you are looking for free, then just set up a directory on your computer and create a new folder for every day, and file these inside a folder for every month. In each folder, put your notes about your trades, your execution logs, and the excel file with the actual price level data along with your comments.
It's super easy to do all this stuff. I can't speak much to how discretionary trades do pre and post trade prep, but I can help you get off the ground with some of the technical stuff maybe.
Best of luck!
Ian
In the analytical world there is no such thing as art, there is only the science you know and the science you don't know. Characterizing the science you don't know as "art" is a fools game.