Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
Ok dont want to over complicate this question, assume trader is profitable and manages Risk to Reward etc, we all know a scalper is usually 1to1 or 2to1, guys trading bigger time frames are 1to3 or 1to4. Only referring to day traders not holding for days, weeks etc. Who makes the most $$$$$ ?
Im not finding much as far as reference articles but Im looking for ranking of these traders and their styles. Im posting something to start us off. Any and all links greatly appreciated
I know this has been discussed many times and i understand the pros and cons just wanted to see if anyone had real data. I know in my link these traders have hold positions, just something I threw out as a beginning link
Hi, as far as retail traders go, the larger your targets and stops the higher the probability of profitability in my opinion and experience. Unfortunately few retail scalpers truly comprehend how direct overhead (slippage and commissions) will slowly bleed their accounts dry. Here is an example in this post comparing scalping with slightly larger targets.
Gary, unfortunately if you continue with this approach the odds are so mathematically stacked against you, you will lose all or nearly all of your money. I would seriously consider a temporary halt to this approach. Here is an extract from my financial …
futures.io (formerly BMT) poll a couple months ago
I am not sure focusing on profit is really the best way to measure things. You probably don't buy a car based on its top speed, and in the corporate world you probably don't take a job solely based on salary. There are other things to consider.
I am in the minority on futures.io (formerly BMT), I don't scalp. I tried that a few years ago and have spent the last couple of years unlearning that behavior and returning to longer term positions, which I find not only more profitable but also far easier to manage.
lol, I was going to mention you in this thread but didnt, yes I know your opinion which I dont disagree with. Your right with it being more than just the money, ie. I like scalping ticks to 4 pts bc i can sit down and trade in mins and be done for day, where as if I have to wait for areas to do business it takes longer more thought is needed to "predict" big target 7-10 pts away, you have to take retracement heat on longer moves,also i dont like leaving trades live while Im not at pc and with my schedule I would have to on longer runs.
But what I want to know is what traders are doing X number, ie. the trader that made 60mil scalping currencies, or trader doing 80mil holding. Info like this is hard to come by. One might ask why would a person want this info. Trading is my business and if I want to increase my profitability then I look at others that have achieved what Im looking to do in todays market.
I understand. But the problem is, you are not them.
I mean the general rules of trading are simple, almost all the big traders will agree - cut your losers quick, let your winners run. Don't add to a bad trade. etc. Beyond this, every traders style is unique to them and is a very personal thing. Copying someone else's methodology is not likely to offer you much success.
So personally I don't care that John made 60 million scalping, and Fred made 80 million swing trading. What I care about is how Big Mike made his millions And that is not going to be copying John or Fred, but instead creating my own path. Just like John and Fred did not copy someone else, they made their own way.
I couldn't agree more. My golden rule is I will never put on a trade where the cost of doing business (slippage and commission) is greater than the house odds of an American style roulette wheel.
The wheel has 35 numbers and 2 zeros so the cost of my trade (commissions and slippage on the stop) cannot be more than 5.7%. To be able to achieve this based on my typical winning percentages the minimum targets and stops are:
Stop 30 ticks
Target 1 30 ticks
Target 2 60 Ticks
This will ensure I do not exceed 6%.
I know that if I start trading smaller targets the odds are turning drastically against me to the point that the odds of winning over the longer term are virtually zero. Now of course using much larger targets such as this swing trade here the overhead cost is just over 1%. This type of trading approach means I am working smarter and not harder. This is what I'm trying to gravitate to for all trades.
Thanks for the interesting thread. I've utilized support and resistance swing trading strategies on equities for 25 years and and believe them to be extremely rewarding setups provided you are patient and wait for the shenanigans to play themselves …
My background as a licensed CPA brought me in contact with many business owners who got into trouble financially. The common theme was many allowed their overheads to spiral out of control whereby their sales were simply insufficient to support their bloated cost structures. Some survived through drastic cost reductions and many had to close down. I remember one example where a business owner spent $30k on a Persian rug which meant he couldn't make payroll for that month.
The point is trading is a business and overheads (commission and slippage) must be kept under control or the trader will, like any business have cash flow problems and have to close down. The problem is many traders continue to employ scalping strategies blowing up account after account blissfully unaware the impact of slippage and commissions.
I agree, I have NEVER followed the same path as the majority. Hence my questions on futures.io (formerly BMT) I get what your saying. i dont know John who made 60mil scalping but I do know John who makes 500k yr and i do know Fred who did 80mil last yr. Im not wanting to copy someones method, i was wanting to see if there was a ranking,articles etc out there that read 750 Johns that made 500k to 1.5 mil scalping and 2300 Freds that made 4 to 400mil trading for pts.
I was always told its never a dumb question unless you dont ask it.
I think that is good in theory. I mean look at the typical ATR on oil over the last few years for each 30 minutes of the trading day. 4 ticks on oil when the ATR for each 30 minutes is over 50 ticks.
The problem with oil as well if you are in a trade and a gust of volatility rears its ugly head and stops you out you can incur slippage of 5 ticks plus. My average slippage on oil for losing trades is 2 ticks which is quite unattractive. The only reason I can withstand this type of rape is because my trades are few and targets larger therefore averaging down my net trading costs.
This is the beauty of position trading, is you pretty much avoid these issues. Plus when a swing trade goes on, I can go and do something else for the day and have some fun with my kids. If I'm going to be glued to the screen all day fretting about a few ticks here and there I may as well have a day job. Sometimes I wake up in the morning or come back down a few k but the winners make up for it.
How will knowing this information make you a better trader?
Perfectly worded I couldnt agree more, I understand everything you said which most dont....Being from CPA world, you and I are the same, I have always started my small businesses from the ground up. I was CFO first so Im used to not having a steady income unless I made the funds come in. Maybe alot of people on here come from salary based jobs Idk but a few days ago I had to help out a close friend that was unside down on a bid contract. Made me think of trading everyone says there isnt other jobs like trading. Hummm what about bid work, government, military, education you bid it sign contract and its up to you to build to spec. so you better have margins built in or pass on it,. Sounds like trading doesnt it, you win or lose big with this type of work