Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
No problem at all with your posting here (even if its accidental) as it's good in some respects to know some are reading my posts....futures i.o is fairly quiet from what I've seen so far compared to other sites...
Now comments:
Nikkei....personally your making it hard on yourself trading that market, with a 5 tic min-move it's an inferior instrument to the Hang Seng....your comments about not getting filled (even though it's the HIGHEST volume asian index) scares the crap out of me (the bid/off 5point is too expensive) ...I'd rate the HHI better value vs the king HSI....I did start-off trading the HHI for a few months before "graduating" to the HSI...HHI is just a bit slower given the scaling.
Lastly, are you trading tick charts for intra day? - I'd never go back to time-based charts after trading tick-charts..just too slow and the levels are not as easy to read. (I realise it's not always available from every data vendor but well worth the cost for scalping)..
Hint - whenever I see consolidation in any market I "know" an explosion of activity is just around the corner..ie good opportunity.....Volatility is cyclical. Some good studies have been done by Tony Crabel - NarrowRange4(NR4) and NR7
for example...food for thought.
From your comment below:
" My stats show we're about 50% of normal volume at this time of day for the ES (computed since Jan 1). So, not a day to expect huge moves."
Did you mean during HK trading hours the ES volume is 1/2 of it's normal volume compared to US trading hours volume?
Can you help answer these questions from other members on NexusFi?
Yeah, Nikkeis are "weird" ... they can consolidate in a 5 tick range for 3 hours and then the last 10 minutes of cash into the futures close they will move 20 ticks .. like they did today. Sure, all instruments do this sometimes, but I've seen Nikkeis do it a LOT ... basically, under most circumstances, after the first hour, until the last 30 minutes, it's no good to trade.
I trade mainly using the ladder, but my intraday structure chart is a volume-based chart, no discernible bars, just a continuous flow. I've been using it for about 7 years with almost no changes. Using this, along with my profile on the ladder, I get a great visual of the consolidations you talk about. I have the visual imprinted onto my brain actually after so long, it's impossible to miss on a volume chart with the bars as small as I have them, which is why I love using that view instead of a time-based chart. Actually at the bottom of my volume chart I have a "bars per time" view so that I still get a visual representation of quick volume.
It was interesting that today when HHI was breaking out after lunch, it had a really nice sustained volume. It has gone higher in the face of lots of selling. I took the breakout and got flat at 10912 near these highs. Basically, China was super bid today .. it's the type of buying that is sustainable, as opposed to the 150 point HSI rips that sell back off. It can be frustrating, in a way, but if you can just get in and trust the bids as long as they hold, it makes for a smoother ride, IMO.
What I meant about the relative volume is that since Jan 1, at 10:30PM ET (2 hours into China cash session), ES has on average traded about 100K. At that point today (2 hours into China), ES had only done 50K. So, I meant that ES has relatively much lower volume than it normally does, at this point in the day.
I am in the process of importing as much data as possible into a local database that I am using to perform basic research. I have not imported HSI/HHI data yet, but I will do this soon, after I get some of my functions written.
Power to you for mastering the volume based charts...you must be onto something good if you have using them for 7 years..wow..it must fit your style of trading well.
So now I understand why your following and comparing the volume between the 2 markets - makes sense with your style of trading......many years ago when the ES started the volumes in Asia were nothing and believe it or not the Hang Seng was a "proxy" for the ES....how times have changed.
It varies, last night was an unusually late night for me. Usually I am done by the China lunch, or maybe 30 minutes after the reopen. I am definitely a night owl, always have been. It's something I've tried to change my whole life but at this point I've decided not to fight it really.
+70 tics - not really reading the chart well today...1 error (a really stupid error as I didnt want to miss the breakout that didn't eventuate) - really DUMB
Snuck in a late trade
in retrospect I missed the 2nd trade of the day which was an instant 20tics that kinda made me NOT want to miss the breakout which caused the error....its a mind-game for sure...need to focus better.
Battle Royal.....behind from the first trade.....fought like crazy for +18tics....but cant see that buried within the 1 lot numbers.. Pat on the shoulder for not giving up..
22 trades....in reality I really should just turn it off if I'm down more than 50 tics but I just couldn't walk away with a loss for the day...