Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now, It is Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
I am so glad your here , The Tech has gotten back with me after I gave him a detailed overview of what I was doing. He has instructed me that I was improperly using the bot and has offered to help. I am grateful that it was pointed out, since I am a new trader, as outlined in my original post.
I am looking forward to continued business with TruTrade.
Thanks,
NTCat
Can you help answer these questions from other members on NexusFi?
Regarding the recent post by member @TruTrade LLC:
1. @TruTrade LLC has received strong criticism and has a right to defend himself. Even though his post contained marketing and promotional claims that would not usually be permitted on futures.io, it will be allowed to stand in order to afford him the opportunity to respond.
2. In the future, @TruTrade LLC will be expected to follow the rules and responsibilities of a vendor posting on the forum. Under the rules stated in the futures.io Terms of Use: "vendors are not permitted to make any posts in which you promote your business in any way. This means no promotional posts linking to your website, blog, videos, screenshots showing indicators or systems, or any discussing of products, services, testimonials." A vendor can respond factually to a direct question about their product by another member, but cannot initiate the discussion and cannot make any promotional claims about how well their product or service performs, nor make any other marketing-related statements. The intention is to provide useful information to the community, not a sales opportunity for the vendor.
Failure to follow these policies may be met with deletion of posts and/or a temporary or permanent ban.
3. TruTrade LLC will be flagged as a vendor, as required in the Terms of Use.
I hope that @ntcat will keep the forum informed about his experiences going forward, if he continues to use this vendor's products in the future.
Bob.
When one door closes, another opens.
-- Cervantes, Don Quixote
The following 2 users say Thank You to bobwest for this post:
I also want to make 100% certain it is clear that the vendor must follow site rules (his first post did not). When anyone joins the community, they are told multiple times about our policies. So consider this the final warning to follow them.
Vendors are free to (and encouraged to) respond to direct inquiries/questions/comments/complaints in their thread, but they are NOT permitted to use posts for marketing purposes or self-promotion. That means that unsolicited posts or unsolicited marketing/promotional language is not permitted. Yes, you can defend yourself without making marketing claims or using promotional language.
I just wanted to chime in on this post as well. I purchased TruTrade back in June and while I cannot as of yet give it a possitive review I cannot give it a negative one either.
When I first came across this company I was very skeptical (since most bots and sales guys just try to run away with your money. ) However the amount of time I was given by the TruTrade team in not only explaining the program but even swapping out products once they found out I bought the wrong one for my trading style really has helped me to keep on trucking with these guys.
I also did my due diligence and when I was investigating the product actually reached out to Ninjatrader to see if their claim to be a be partner was true. They did confirm that they were completing the partnership process and would be on ninjatraders website later that month.
The fact that ninjatrader was willing to put their name on the product convinced me to purchase.
Now the reasons why I sometimes wonder if I made the right choice.
1) The bot is inconsistent (I currently have then trend following version) and honestly takes some very stupid trades. Going long after hitting long term resistance seems to be it's biggest loser. Now I cannot blame the bot for this yet because as I was told multiple times you have to get the bar size right for the market conditions. I have seen the bot work amazing, especially in short term scalps, but it is no so much in long term plays. I will keep playing with bar sizes and figure out how to calculate it and report back on actual results.
2) there isn't any clear pricing. No pricing sheet, no transparency on the site etc. When I purchased I was told this is the price what what you are purchasing but there wasnt anything sent to me that showed all their products and the prices associated. For me it wasn't a huge deal but for others it might be sketchy
3) no long term support - now typically if you are going to drop thousands on a software you expect that if you have questions (especially regarding the most critical function of bar sizes) support would be readily available but unfortunately it is not. For technical issues like licensing or error messages they are very fast and responsive. But for other questions (like bar sizes) it is very generic or non helpful. Now one could argue that giving support on bar sizes for example falls more in line with trading training. However I would counter that with this - since the whole bots success and calculations are 100% based on your bar size then that no longer is a trading question and becomes a software question. It is the same as selling me a computer and showing me where the power button is and saying everything else you have to figure out on your own. Again Danny spent the time with me to show me the different contracts the bot does well with, the times of day he typically trades and his typical bar type so they did give me at no extra charge a lot of great information. However with how dynamic markets are there should be something more programmic to the bar sizes then, whatever works best today.
Overall I am optimistic about TruTrade. I believe they are trying to be an honest broker. They are a new company that is trying to figure out how to sell their products and do right by their customers. Trading is a tough business and nothing is guaranteed. I have at least not lost money trading the bot live but I haven't won very much either. (couple hundred). I also haven't been using it very much. I used it daily in June where it actually pulled in 4K in profits and then in July it took out almost all of that in a wild NQ whiplash so I stopped using it after the second week in July. This week I am trying to focus 100% on trutrade and crack this dang bar size code. Hopefully once I do I can come back and report great results.
If not then hopefully my story can help another trader and I'll stick to good ol orderflow trading and forget bots and strategies all together.
When I first posted this message my intent was to get some info from other people who has used also the software in the past.
I was having a bit of hard time understanding what the bot was actually doing. Also I did not want to be a part of some well known scam, that I was not aware of. I am in talks with TruTrade and I was offered a bit of retraining. I think the first time I was just asking so many questions and not paying attention to what the Tech was telling me. After watching the reply many times I might have side tracked the training accidentally. I have recorded our time just so that I could review it later. The recordings are for private use only and cannot be shared.
I might have mentioned in an email to TruTrade that pointed to this site, My goal or my thought process is that a company if they were a scam would not dare reply a public forum. But to my surprise they did. My bad, Sorry.
Here are some of the mistakes I made,
1. SIM Trade First - Because there is more to it than turning it on and waiting for payday.
2. Identify the Trend using their methods
What I may have done is log into my bot and just turned it on.. I stuck a wireless ear piece in and worked at my 9 to 5 job until I heard it take a trade. Some times it would take hours for it to do anything, I may have gotten a bit of FOMO when I did not see it do anything happening.
What they stressed is they want me be successful and if I am not they can't sell me anything else.
They told me they are true to their word, and that honestly is very important
We have a meeting setup for Friday 7 August 2020 to go over the settings and how to correctly use the automation software.
I will keep everyone updated on my progress.
The following 2 users say Thank You to ntcat for this post:
I am pretty much in the same boat... TruTrade put some information out rently maybe around 1 July ish that I did not have when I first bought the automation..
TruTrade and I finally was able to meet up and I had my retraining last night.
We went over the bot and basics of training. It definitely had some golden nuggets that I needed. Now keep in mind that I did paid for the extra training, hopefully I am getting more training and suggestions of settings an a normal user would have.
Here is what we went over...
1. SIM Trade for at least 1-3 Months (Until I feel confortable using the bot in a consistant manner) watch and learn how to bot trades.
2. Don't set and forget the bot. The automation is used for the best entry, but I must take profit or go "Flat" in order to lock in profits.
3. Once you have met your goal for the day, stop trading.... don't over trade.
4. Danny Suggested some settings to stay away from until I understand the bot better. There are several times he told me Don't mess with X setting, your 6 months away before you will understanding what X does. Stick with Y first until you have a greater understanding. Even though he did tell me not to mess with a few settings he still let me know what they did.
5. Don't adjust a bunch of settings at once, Make an adjustment and back test your new settings.
6. Different elements will have different settings.
I made sure to take really good notes, jotting down helpful nuggets of information.
I just started my own jounal in excell so I can review the changes I have made over a period of time. This way I can track the best settings for each element.
What you don't get from TruTrade....
1. They don't tell you what or how trade, they advise you to play with the settings and see what works better for the element your are trading.
TruTrade is becoming more transparent, they are posting regular youTube Videos, posted on their website. I see more suggested bar settings are listed on their website. Danny mentioned they are working on creating a video that will go into depth about their settings that should be ready soon for there members.
Overall I think the extra training was worth it, but they are quick to let you know they are not an education site and experienced traders should already know most of the basics, they review. It was helpful to me because I just wanted to know more.
Last night I applied some the tips, and made $166 in the short time I messed with it. I got up early this morning before work and made the rest.
If anyone is wanting to see the results I will post it here after a week or so, just to make sure this is not a fluke. I am still in the experimental stage....
I am trading MES, NQ and GC, at 1 or 2 contracts, once I got the best settings down, I will experiment with others.
Thanks,
NTCat
The following user says Thank You to ntcat for this post:
I'd like to clarify, that is Not a fact. NinjaTrader never puts their name on any vendor or product. There is a very good reason why NT calls us vendors and not partners, because NT does not partner with any of us vendors. What NT does do during the sign-on process (and this is no secret. NT is open about this) is they make sure the vendor's web site complies with federal agency regulations. Most notably, claims of profitability by the vendor. And, make sure the disclaimers are clearly visible, as required by the various federal agencies. I think they do a background check on the company owner(s), nowadays, but not positive on that. That's a summarization of what it takes to be listed in NT vendor ecosystem. This is not intended to discredit TruTrade, just clarification on what NT's logos signify on a vendor's website.
If you really think about it, there is no way that NT could positively verify some other company is "on the up and up". There would be intellectual property concerners by the vendors. Plus, the tremendous amount of man hours it would take for someone at NT to investigate everthing a vendor is selling.
They will de-list a company/vendor if they receive enough complaints with "substance" to make a good circumstantial case against the vendor.
For what its worth, this is what I know and have seen being a NT vendor.
Maybe NinjaTrader would like to add-to or clarify any of this?
The best way to determine if a company is reputable is to read the reviews on here. Remember to pay it forward by adding your experiences with any company to the review posts as well.
Assuming your bar size has been optimized for the instrument if you are churning your account it's generally because of entry 2.
The Entry 2 quantity should be at least 2 to 3 times greater than the entry 1 quantity
The recommended entry 2 target distances for each instrument are listed below:
ES, YM, RTY, CL, GC 4-6 ticks
NQ, RB 8 – 12 ticks
Keep in mind these are just recommendations to use as starting values. Entry 2 was designed to provide a defense mechanism for dealing with periods of low-volatility price consolidation. If the entry 2 quantity is not at least 2-3 times greater than the entry 1 quantity or the entry 2 target distance is too far from the fill price the bot will have little or no defense in low volatility environments. Hope this helps
*Your a new trader please make sure you sim a bit longer to get fully comfortable. Drop us an email if you need anything else. very happy your seeing results its what its all about
The following user says Thank You to TruTrade LLC for this post:
Appreciate your reply: As we mentioned on an earlier post. were set-up and went through their long process, checks etc....NT just didn't add value and was no benefit to TT. We simply came off for that reason. Ryan at NT understood and it was tru trade that left. not a big deal. We hope all of our clients have great experiences and we still send tons of clients to NT love the platform.
It's always nice to hear customer feedback we always do our best to help and improve client experience. Both clients that chimed in this post are good to go and is extremely important to us that they are, hence this post
yes, would be nice if NT or Ryan jumped in and clarified, would be great
The following 2 users say Thank You to TruTrade LLC for this post: