Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
As a generalization I sell weekly 30 delta puts on stocks that I'd be happy to own. Those short puts are sometimes part of a long put spread and all the option deltas are in the consideration of "neutral"
Sometimes I have to roll the puts but most of the time they expire. Again, generally speaking you want to sell puts (long delta) when people are scrambling to buy insurance. Vola is exploding. Puts are bid up. This is fairly complex...meaning sometimes difficult...but like any insurance underwriter, the metrics for evaluation are there.
On that strategy that you described. Trying to sound humble...I do not usually marry puts at the time of purchase. Rather i try to convince myself that I'm buying long stock at a good price and owning for a very long time. I put all of my dividends on reinvestment and consider heavily 5 yr div growth rates and payout ratio, among other items when looking at stocks to own.
I will add protection by owing a long put, but most of my long puts are SPY puts. I buy those if I need a known downside for my short exposure...unfortunatly that element is something I have NOT mastered.
Maybe the right place is one of the Es threads if guys want to have a discussion.
Short the ES for as long as it takes. That is never the goal to have a short Es position for weeks, but it happens. I'm short a few more than I like from net 2917 right now.
The ES position does not have to be static. I do trade that both sides intra day if I think there is a good set up. Sometimes I improve my position, sometimes I screw it up, but if I'm neutral I have a theoretical basis for any outcome.
it might help to say that a position does not have to be static/dynamic or binary to make money. Maybe it is appropriate to say that what I am describing is the ES trade as an element of a bigger picture. Are most members thinking of ES as an intra-day long or short... in an exclusive way. Meaning, I trade the ES for directional moves while the market is open (RTH)?
My question would be, that's cool, but why are you making time the enemy?
A legitimate, but in my opinion, unfortunate answer is that margin/deposit wont allow carry. Day trading the most competitive market in the world is, perhaps, the most difficult vocation on the planet.
It can be done, for sure...but I do not think that I could have done it on my best days, much less for a career.
on that issue. You could pick any stock to be long. Then you could trade the /MES against it delta neutral. See, that calculation is Beta weighted. I should have included that all along. Now, a stock that is an element of the index, especially one that is a significant percent of the index, that is less that 290 ish per share does make the deposit required more tenable.
You can illustrate this manually peg a stock purchase and then the sell of a future against it. At the end of the day check the closing prices relative to the peg (trade price). You will see that most of the time the relationship is reliable...not always, but over time. Then if you look at the price action of both during the day you will see in the divergence and convergence of the two areas where you could have taken a leg.
I know that sounds complicated, but its not once you have a handle on it.
What a timely poll. Only on FIO can futures traders openly discuss the disparity between the REALITY of their trading (mis)adventures compared the the EXPECTATIONS without having to be anonymous! I love this site.
I have been trying for over a decade to trade one (just 1) contract of YM or NQ on a $1,500 or $2,000 account. And the market seems to know exactly when I enter every trade, as if to say "Steve is back! Let's show him AGAIN what an idiot he is!" And "When will he learn that 4 losses in a row of $150 wipes out half his account?" And "Major Loser!!"
For the past 3 years I have been dealing with this "Undercapitalized!!!" issue by trying out TST, OneUp, and LeeLoo. And I succeeded. I have been funded by MES capital after passing the OneUp trial 4 times now, and I am FINALLY being profitable. I have an account now that will allow me to trade multiple Emini contracts with a large enough draw down to make it through some bad trades. It has made ALL THE DIFFERENCE in my stress level and ability to be profitable.
Because of my success, I have been recommending the "Funded Trader" route to my friends, with the caveat that they better be able to win on a sim account 5 days in a row FIRST. These evaluations are NOT a practice field, but a money sink if you are not prepared to follow all the rules and do it right the first time. (You can review my FIO OneUp/MES journal here.)
Now something amazing happened last month. I have been hoping for micro indicies for a long time, and they finally arrived! I have since been toying around with the MES, MNQ and MYM. They are 1/10 the size of the Emini's. This doesn't mean that I don't make bad trades, it just means I don't die as fast. Because the commission is twice as costly as the Emini's per unit of gain ($.80 micro vs $4.00 Emini) I readily admit these are only to get someone started. But it is still exciting.
And now I tell people to avoid the combines all together and just open a $2,000 account and trade one (just 1) micro position at a time to start. That is like a $20k Emini account! According to a 2015 survey the average trader spent $1,145 on TopStep Trader. I now say FORGET TST, OneUP, LeeLoo, Earn2Trade, and all the rest. So put the combine money into your own account! And away we go.
Now trade the Micros. And watch in amazement as you patiently grow your war chest. Try to make just $20 per day to start on your $2000 account. That is 1% per day. Add one micro contract with each $300 you make. At 1% per day, you will have $24,000 at the end of 250 trading days. Once your account reaches $5,000, then switch over to the Emini's. Keep going at 1% per day using one Emini contract. This is just a $50 gain. Then add another contract with each $5,000 to $10,000 in your account. At the end of one year you will be trading with 1 to 4 contracts and conservatively making $238 per day. You will have $24,000.
You can keep scaling to your comfort level during the second year. At 1% per day, at the end of 500 trading days, you would be making over $2,500 per day and have over $250,000 in your account.
I think the Eminis are awesome and should help a lot of people bring their Realities closer to their Expectations.
Hey Steve, It is a wise approach you are offering. Let's have a look at it from the point of view who just came to that field and thinking he is going to make $1500 in 1 hours as there are many videos stating on youtube. When we are coming to trading we are seeing that we can get reach quick. At least this is what i thought when i join the club.
Most of us didn't realised that it is a marathon and not a sprint.
What you wrote above is already a plan for 1 year plus. Who wants to do it? When ppl wants to have it here and now.
At the end of the day the sooner trader realise that it is a Marathon and not a sprint the quicker he will progress.
With a micros now it is a truly a best approach to get your foot wet.
Fantastic post, @wldman There's so much to take from it that I can't put it in one post.
But since no one else mentioned it, congrats to you for handling that situation with aplomb. I've unfortunately never worked in trading but I can't imagine setting someone up to possibly fail like that. I feel like I know how that conversation went with that trader after they got back from vacation. I am glad you got the desk, and if it were up to me I would have promoted and/or bonused that great person from the wholesaler desk that did more to help you in minutes than the other person did in a week and a half.
Anyway enough of that, over time I'd like to learn more about these time frame expansion strategies you are describing.
July 2018 I stumbled upon a video on YouTube about a daytrader’s ‘lifestyle.’ It seemed glorious and instantly had me hooked on the prospect of overnight success and great riches.
One month later I bought a course. There was plenty of BS, but I did learn some crucial elements of trading from the upstart. The teacher stressed again and again the importance of having a plan and sticking to that plan. He also had the same reaction to a big win as to a big loss. This was an important psychological trait to witness as emotional detachment from results is a crucial element of profitable trading.
In true beginner fashion, I abandoned the aforementioned method approximately one month later, after losing money trading live. Who woulda thought I’d lose money going live after two weeks of learning!
For the next four months I bounced around testing countless indicator combinations and ‘surprisingly’ found nothing of substance!
In January I happened upon Damian Castilla’s videos on YouTube as well as his thread on forexfactory. It amazed me that he could consistently lock in $10,000+ sized wins without any indicators on his screen. I began to learn Damian’s methods of price action and acquired bits and pieces from other members on his thread. I demo traded for two months and broke even for the most part. I then opened a live account and traded SPY (SP500) ETF with small risk (approx 1-2 MES). I actually came out in the green by a small margin.
Fast forward to now, I decided in June to move up to 1 ES contract. June has been a green month!
When I began trading I expected to win overnight. That did not happen. When I restarted my trading journey with price action I expected to be able to get to profitability but did not know how long it would take. Now I am 1 year into my journey and have had a profitable month. It would be foolish and naive to assume that because I’ve had one good month I am now consistently profitable... BUT it is a start and I am on my way to consistently tipping the scale to the green side!