Welcome to NexusFi: the best trading community on the planet, with over 150,000 members Sign Up Now for Free
Genuine reviews from real traders, not fake reviews from stealth vendors
Quality education from leading professional traders
We are a friendly, helpful, and positive community
We do not tolerate rude behavior, trolling, or vendors advertising in posts
We are here to help, just let us know what you need
You'll need to register in order to view the content of the threads and start contributing to our community. It's free for basic access, or support us by becoming an Elite Member -- see if you qualify for a discount below.
-- Big Mike, Site Administrator
(If you already have an account, login at the top of the page)
-95 Ouch!!! This has been MY trading in the last couple of days as well. Blew account! (Fell below margin)
I got frustrated that my method wasnt providing more. After a week of going live I was break even. (I think my max intraday drawdown was -36 POINTS-ish! Still, whatever your -# is you now need to get +# just to break even... including any -# along the way.)
I did not like having to trade +36 points just to BREAK EVEN! Even though mostly i did. But slowly this started me trading crazy, thinking I was using logic. Thinking I'll just cut this... let that ride... crap... reverse... crap... stop... move stop... crap...
Well...
Going back to tying to make a few POINTS by NEVER touching if in profits till targets hit. I start with wide initial stops and can tighten but NEVER widen. I try not to break even unless I can cover at least two commissions and its already gone against me at least once. Those are about my only rules. (Also going to try with two contracts so I can scale but thats besides the point)
You are a fire hydrant of information. I have no idea how you keep up with it all. Lol Very impressive. I just try to get in and manage my trade.
Like all your detailed information though its great. Thank you!
Just thought you might try testing a few of those rules I mentioned above. If you have and I'm out of line I apologize. Just some thoughts.
Trade 1: Short high range (IBH, YH, ONH) for a 4pt mean reversion trade to the VPOC @3205.25. Scratched for -2t. Target reached after exit.
Trade 2: Long BOPB 5m OR (and at VAH support) for trend continuation, -10t.
Trade 3: Re-entry (trade 2) long, -3t.
Trade 4: Re-entry (trade 2) long for 4t.
Trade 2, 3 and 4 were actually one trade to catch a with-trend move up. Market went sideways for 1.5h (lunch time).
Trade 5: Short PB for a gap close (target YC & ONL), -10t. Entry is in the middle of the range, trend is up.
Trade 6: Long PB, 4t. No follow through.
Trade 7: Short (just below VAH) for a mean reversion trade to VPOC, -7t. No follow through, sideways and up.
Trade 8: Re-entry short, -8t.
Trade 9: Long on impulse, -3t.
Trade 10: Re-entry (trade 8) short, -8t.
Trade 11: Re-entry (trade 8) short, -24t.
Total loss 16.75 points (2 small winners, 9 losers)
I am clearly not in sync with the market. May take a break to work things out.
I really was not content with my trading and took some time off to work things out.
I am very hard trying to make every day, or even every trade, a positive one. This leads to forcing trades (with bad timed entries/exits), FOMO, revenge trading and ultimately overtrading. This is not how successful trading is supposed to be.
I don't think trading a lot is necessarily a bad thing (when scalping) but it is when it's motivated by a feeling to prove something, an urge to make up for losses made or trying to get even. Revenge trading comes in all kind of flavors. I guess a mental trading coach can help with this but as a retail trader you don't have access to a trustworthy first class coach and I wonder if reading Brett Steenbarger, Mark Douglas and the like will be enough. You still have to do it yourself. I believe trading is not so much a technical game, this can be learned, but more a mental game. I studied a lot on this subject and still struggle with the implementation.
This journal is like a mirror and really helps to reflect on my trading. I believe that going through this process will take me a step further and that's why I continue my journal.
So back to the basics. Identify a setup and trade this setup the best you can over a certain period of time. This will be my goal for the rest of the month.
I trade one instrument (MES) and using only one setup may give too little signals during the day. That's why I will stay with the setups mentioned in post #2. Additional to these setups I may take a Mean Reversion (MR) trade from Valua Area High/Low (VAH/VAL) to the Volume Point of Control (VPOC) in a balanced market.
- Skipped the gap close on the open (after rejecting higher prices in the first three minutes and test & reject YVAH 3214.50 & ON VPOC 3215).
- Skipped 1st 1m PB (to ema20, VWAP & YVPOC, 1st cross sell), target YVAL, ONL, YL (1st PB after open, 2nd from swing high).
- Trade 1: Short PB. Closed bc no follow through (and possible 2nd leg PB). Late in swing down and buying from the last swing low looked strong (with wide green candles which signal at least a possible 2nd leg).
- Missed 2nd leg PB (abc) short for test ONL & YL (didn't want to get in so soon after the last trade but I should have, was a nice (re-)entry with a lower high on the 2nd leg which signals there's no more buying).
- Low range support at 3183.25 (low of last swing to the high June 8th / 60m).
- Not taking the first PB (1m 1st cross buy) after the first swing up from the low bc still down on the 3m and below VWAP. But above support (ONL, YL, 60m low range, oversold 15m).
- 11:00 ET: 3 pushes down & SOT (3m).
- 11:36 ET: trapped shorts but not going long into swing high resistance (from 10:41).
- Trade 2: BOF at prior swing high (10:41) (mean reversion scalp to HVN / VPOC)
Total 3.75 pts
Levels ON: ONH 3188.50, ONL 3098.25, VPOC 3131.75, VAH 3158.50, VAL 3107.50, HVN 3103.25.
Scenarios:
1. Market comes to a halt and grinds sideways (ranging). Sell on range high / VAH resistance and buy at range low / VAL support. Use VPOC and range opposite as targets.
2. Continuation of the downtrend. Sell on PBs & upside BOFs. Trade towards lower levels.
3. Reversal of EU downtrend and gap close (test ON & yesterday's levels): Buy on PBs & downside BOFs towards higher levels.
Trade 1: Long on a pullback after an impulse up on the 30s. Exit at RTH open, scalp for 2.5 pts.
Trade 2: Short on a pullback for 3.5 pts. Exit at low. Entry into support, not much potential.
Trade 3: Short pullback for 5 pts. Exit at low. Late in move down.
Total 11 pts.
Trade 1 and 2 were scalps within the first hour range. Trade 3 was a nice with-trend entry but very late in the move down.
Scenario 2 played out after ranging for an hour (scenario 1). I didn't play it as planned. I had better focused on an short entry on a pullback to ema20 early on in the day (or an upside BOF) and held it till it closed above ema20.
Three winners out of three but I missed the whole move down and didn't act as planned.
It's a constant battle. I must push myself hard to do the right thing and that is to enter & exit according to my rules and play the scenarios as I planned them.
I didn't start well today. I was late with my market preparation and hadn't enough time to write it down. Doing my market preparation before the open is important. It brings me in tune with the market and acts like a kind of map. It's also good for confidence build up. If doing my preparation during market open I am already behind. Price opened inside yesterday's range above value near ONH. I decided to wait for the market to show some direction. After 20 minutes things lined up.
Trade 1: Short 30s 2-leg pullback (ABC) which is a pullback on a higher time frame (3m). There was no immediate follow through and buying came in so I closed the trade for 2x 0.5 pt. I want to see it going right out of the gate or else I am out. Because of the buying and lack of supply I didn't re-enter. There was also a possibility for a mean reversion to the VPOC. Take as less risk as possible. There is always another opportunity.
Trade 2: Short on pullback. Closed again on buying for 4.75 pts. There were some nice levels below (YC, YVPOC, ONL) which act as a magnet and once achieved can attract buying. It's a pity I missed a nice and rather straightforward move.
Trade 3: Long on PB. Closed BE.
Total 5.75 pts.
I had problems with my charts. At one moment there was a 10 pt spread between the ES and the MES. Looked like the ES was lagging behind and could not keep up with the MES. Could be a problem caused by roll-over, wrong data or last NT version which I installed this morning. Whatever, I could not trade anymore and stopped for the day.
Price @2964.00 is below yesterday's low and below value 2992.75. Bearish.
Market sold-off in Asia session, came back in EU session (to daily level @2981.50). On 60m: downtrend (3 pushes down, buy divergence). On 15m: ranging. On 3m: ranging
Scenarios:
1. On bearish strength: sell towards ONL, daily level 2893.25.
2. On bullish strength: buy towards ONH, daily level 2981.50, YVPOC, YC (Gap fill)
3. When ranging: sell VAH, buy VAL towards VPOC.
These are just notes for myself! Don't use it to trade on.
Trade 1: Long PB (lower time frame) for -5.25 pts. Entry is too early. Need to be patient. Wait for a 3m ema20 PB. Now it's more a breakout trade (into prior swing high resistance). Bad entry.
Trade 2: Re-entry long PB for -3.50 pts. Need to be patient. See Trade 1.
Trade 3: Re-entry long PB for 10 pts. This is the correct entry. Nice 3m ema20 PB and almost 50% retracement. Out at daily level. Just wait for the right entry.
Trade 4: Long PB for -2.75 pts. Too early, see trade 1. We were now inside yesterday's value and it looked like YVAL was support (buying). Played for next level which is yesterday's naked VPOC. I should have recognized we just reached target ONH (which became IBH). Also, the swing was extended and due for a pullback. Bad entry.
Trade 5: Re-entry long PB for -3 pts. Too early. See trade 4.
Trade 6: Short mean reversion to 3m ema20 & VPOC for 3.75 pts. Closed a little early. VPOC was hit for a potential 2.5 pts extra.
Trade 7: Long PB (trend continuation) for 1.25 pts. Play for ONH/IBH, YVPOC and YC.
Trade 8: Re-entry long PB for 5.50 pts. Chickened out. Should at least wait till last high at ONH & IBH (for a test).
Trade 9: Long on support at ONH / IBH (after breakout) for -3 pts. Stopped on PB.
Trade 10: Long PB (YVAL provided support) for 7.25 pts. Played for YVPOC (naked). Closed little too early (on consolidation on lower time-frame). YVPOC was hit for a potential 4.5 pts extra.
Trade 11: Long PB for a test of the high and possibly YH. Closed for 0.75 pts based no follow through.
No more trades as I had problems with my NinjaTrader charts again (just like last Friday). When things get a little more volatile ES is lagging. I use ES and MES on one chart which I think may be causing the problem. I am thinking to just watch and trade the MES and see how that turns out.
Total profit for the day is 11 pts.
Scenario 2 played out. On bullish strength: buy towards ONH, daily level 2981.50, YVPOC, YC (Gap fill)
Placed 1 mean reversion (counter-trend ) trade and 10 (with-trend) long trades from which a couple with a too early entry resulting in a loss. In total 5 losers & 6 winners. Today I was good positioned with the trend. I should try to be a little more patient with my entries and let the winners run a little further so they can reach target.